GPS Map Update Costs
Garmin and TomTom both announced map update subscriptions this year, following on the heels of the impressive NAVIGON FreshMaps offer. Magellan has yet to announce any sort of map update subscription. Garmin offers a one time fee for “lifetime” maps, TomTom’s offer is on an annual basis, and with NAVIGON you get three two (it used to be three) years. Confusing? Yes. But we are here to help you sort it all out and find out who has the cheapest map updates for the North America GPS market.
Pay as You Go
There are two models for getting map updates these days, subscription, and paying for an individual map. If you pay for an individual map you decide how often you want to update the map for your device. This can be the “safe” play if you don’t know how long you will keep your current GPS. These updates run about $70 – $120 depending on the vendor and the type of map purchased. Garmin typically charges about $70 for a single update, Magellan about $80, and TomTom charges about $80 – $90 depending on the map technology. (These prices are for North America maps.)
Subscription Updates
For more hard-core GPS users however, purchasing a map update subscription might be the way to go. Typically you will pay a price up-front and get a new map update four times per year. These updates come out roughly each quarter. If you intend to keep your GPS device for a long time, or just demand the most up-to-date maps available– this might be your choice.
The way each company has chosen to offer the updates varies quite a bit, so let’s break it down. Garmin offers a “lifetime” subscription package which is the easiest to understand. A new device comes with a 60 day “latest map guarantee” and from there you can pay $120 and get map updates each quarter for a “lifetime”. Lifetime means “until your product’s useful life expires or Garmin no longer receives map Data from NAVTEQ, whichever is shorter.”
NAVIGON’s map subscription package is similar. While cheaper at around $80, it does not offer maps for a lifetime– instead you will get the quarterly releases for three years.
Finally TomTom’s offering allows you to pay for a subscription on an annual basis, and receive quarterly map updates. There is one small catch though in that you need to already have the latest map on your device to purchase the subscription. The cost of getting “up to date” to start the subscription is pro-rated based on how old your current map is.
It is also important to remember that these map update subscriptions are tied to the device they are purchased for and are not transferrable.
Breaking it Down
Given that all of the programs are a little bit different, let’s setup a map subscription scenario and then apply it equally to each manufacturer, then compare the map update costs over the years.
In our scenario, you are purchasing a new GPS device today. You get the device, turn it on, register it, and start using the device. For Garmin, TomTom, and Magellan owners you take advantage of the latest map guarantee offers they have to get you up and running on the most current map. Within three months, you are ready to purchase a map subscription for your device, and you want to receive a new map update every quarter.
MSRP Pricing
For this scenario, you will also pay the MSRP price. This is where things can get a bit fuzzy… While the Navigon FreshMaps subscription is $79, I’ve occasionally seen it as low as $35. The same goes for Garmin’s Lifetime Maps product that retails at $120, but I’ve seen it some places as low as $95. TomTom also sometimes offers sale prices on map updates, but I would not expect to see any price reductions on their map subscription.
(Note that Magellan doesn’t currently offer quarterly updates, only annually. Therefore in the graph below each “circle” represents a time when you will get a new map.)
Final Fix
(click the image for a larger view)
As you can see, the cost to keep your maps current depends on how long you think you will keep the device. It will be a bit of a gamble. If you are only going to keep your GPS for a year, then the TomTom updates will cost the least and the Garmin updates will be quite excessive.
Keep the device for two years and costs become relatively close… TomTom and Navigon have the cheapest plan here, although the GO models from TomTom are a tiny bit more. Garmin is still the most expensive.
Hold on to your GPS for three years and we begin to see a flip. Navigon is the most expensive Garmin with the TomTom GO line in the middle. The TomTom ONE and XL lines are pretty much tied with Garmin as the least expensive in this range.
Finally if you manage to keep your GPS for four years the Garmin NuMaps Lifetime product starts to really pay off and will by far be the least expensive. The Navigon and TomTom products really start to add up and me more expensive my a notable margin.
Which is Right for YOU?
Looking out four years seems like a gamble. You might buy a car with a factory installed GPS. You might very well be tempted by newer GPS technology that will come out in newer devices. Your device might break out of warranty making a repair impractical. (Garmin did tell me that if your device breaks and you return it under RMA and they exchange the device, they will make sure you can keep your subscription on the new device.)
Take a look around at any other consumer electronics devices you have– how old are those on average? I’m not a typical consumer, but most all of my gadgets are two years old or less. That would make the Garmin subscription very expensive compared to other brands… but that’s not to say I must go the subscription route either… I could very well just purchase a single update after one year.
All Packaged Up
And then there are devices like the TeleNav Shotgun which come “included” with map update subscriptions with their service fees. With a two year service subscription you pay about $9.95 per month– however for that price you also get the traffic service, mileage tracking, internet connected search, etc.
One final thought to keep in mind. While Navigon guarantees thed update price for three years and Garmin does the same for the life of the device, TomTom only sells a yearly subscription, with no assurance that the offer will continue next year for the same price.
I’m not sure what Garmin means by \useful life\. I’m afraid to buy a subscription for my Nuvi 200. At what point does Garmin consider the Nuvi 200 no longer \useful\?
Plus, Garmin is vague about the quarterly updates. It sounds like there may be quarterly updates or there may not be. It feels like a dirty contract to me.
By “useful life” I understand they mean “for as long the device works”. Since the subscription can’t be transferred to a different device, I think they say it meaning that once your device no longer works, your subscription can’t continue (obvious).
I don’t think they say “useful life” meaning they could one day decide your Nuvi is no longer “useful” and stop your subscription.
This is only my understanding. I might be wrong.
That is my understanding as well, with the additional caveats Garmin mentioned such as the possibility that your device might not have enough memory in the future for the same map coverage.
Well, what if “usefull life” means the life for which Garmin supports it ? What if a discontinued product appears as “non-usefull” product ? I hope that should not be the case but what if this be the case ?
As an owner of an “orphan” GPS (no more updates, so far as I know), I take the lifetime question seriously.
PND technology is now mature. Sure, newer ones have more bells and whistles, but 3 years or more is not an unreasonable lifetime. (My current GPS with 3 year old technology gets me where I want to go just fine.) Moreover, prices have fallen about as far as they are likely to go when considering the costs of the components, necessary sales expenses, and so on.
It is common in the software industry for vendors to simply declare that a version has “reached the end of it’s useful life.” Is that the policy of any GPS vendor?
As to costs, consider that right now you can buy a Garmin Nuvi 255 very cheaply, as it is being superseded by newer models, even though these new models really don’t have many new features (they are slimmer, I guess). If maps will be available for the older 255 for, say, three years, the low price makes for a great deal. But if the 255 “lifetime” is, say, one year, it would be a terrible investment.
No manufacturer can or will support a device for eternity. But how about following typical software policies, in which vendors announce an end-of-life schedule (e.g, the Microsoft XP schedule, which explains how long support will be available).
Just thought I’d let you in on the European situation:
Last time I heard from Garmin officials here in Sweden (during a retailer information evening in October) they were releasing one update per year. Pricing seems to be around €80-100 for one update or €120 for “lifetime”.
Navigon FreshMaps, four updates per year during two years, costs €90-99. With the 2110 max, 2150 max & 7210 max models you currently get a 80% discount here in Sweden, and with the 8110 one FreshMaps subscription is included.
TomTom releases four updates per year, subscription prices vary, but a year with European maps is about €100-110. However you can also subscribe to updates for smaller regions, Nordic countries for example costs about €35-40.
In any case, from my point of view, it’s simply hard to recommend Garmin currently, due to the lack of map updates.
Alexander, your conversation with the Distributor happened well before Garmin announced their quarterly update plans and the map subscription. Not claiming (yet) that Garmin has committed to quarterlies in Europe, but only that at the time of your meetings, Garmin did not offer either of the programs.
Indeed, however they did receive quite a lot of flak from us during the evening, especially when they claimed there were no plans to up the frequency of updates, due to their economic situation.
Of course, they might have reconsidered since, however in that case they don’t seem to have improved on the other point we criticised; lack of info updates to us retailers.
Furthermore, I just got word today from our TomTom supplier that the GO730/930 models here will include 2 years of updates (8 updates), and additionally the GO730T will include one year of speed camera updates. Quite nice tbh.
Garmin is probably the most secretive of all the GPS manufacturers. I’ve had them verbally tell me of “no plans” or “perhaps in a month”, then see a formal announcement of exactly what I enquired about the very next day. Features other companies might brag about go almost unmentioned in Garmin marketing materials. I sympathize with you. I’m sure it makes your sales planning very difficult. But in any case, I do expect quarterly updates for EU. Waiting on an written email confirmation before I state it for a fact, tho I did get a verbal yesterday.
Received written confirmation that EU maps (as well as NA) will be released quarterly.
If only they could have given us a hint about this change.. We could have sold a lot more of their products, because in the end, updated maps is probably one of the (if not THE) most important features.
As far as your nuvi at some point in the future having insufficient storage for a full map or details equal to your current map, that applies already to the TomTom’s TA maps. In some cases they already have reduced detail or data compared to the maps which may have been supplied with the original purchase. I think the same would apply to any device from any manufacturer purchased today. No assurance that future full map releases will fit in today’s storage.
The 7×0’s, 2×0’s and 3×0’s are already discontinued. . . but still supported. They also are eligible for the Lifetime Maps program. I think everyone is trying to read too much into the offer IMHO, and expecting the worst. Neither Garmin nor TomTom is committed to quarterly updates on a set timeframe. In actuality TomTom has (almost) never yet released a map update 90 days after the previous one. Some have been nearly a month after the 90 day schedule. Garmin guarantees you’ll receive every update they release, whether 3 a year or 5, free for the lifetime of your device. Not when they discontinue it and not some arbitrary decision that it’s too old. TomTom guarantees their price for 4 updates only. No guarantee that their offer next year will be as affordable, nor even that they will offer it at all. Navigon has changed their FreshMaps to 2 years rather than 3. The only manufacturer to offer any assurance at all of future update costs is Garmin. The other two are only a guess and a hope IMO.
I think it is just as much of a stretch to suggest that TomTom will jack up the price in the future as it is to suggest that Garmin would take advantage of the “useful life” clause and not provide new maps. To call it a “guess and a hope” is a bit of a stretch. If I took that argument seriously then I’d turn it around and say that Garmin’s offer has a prerequisite that they are still getting maps from NAVTEQ. Not even a year ago they made a bid to purchase another mapping company. Things change fast.
I think you are reading too much into the offer that TomTom isn’t requiring you to plunk down several years of map update cash now. If I recall correctly, you said you haven’t purchased the lifetime subscription offer from your Garmin? Why not? Not sure you will keep the device for long enough to get value out of it? I think the fact that you haven’t yet purchased the lifetime map product suggests the lower cost/shorter term subscriptions have appeal and value.
I love you man.
All PND companies above are bound to the release cycle of the map makers Navteq and TeleAtlas, which is quarterly for the time being (I don’t see that changed until they initiate incremental updating though).
It’s up to Garmin, Tomtom et al to follow that schedule or to release less, but don’t expect them to release more than 4 updates a year.
Good guess as to why I haven’t taken advantage of the Lifetime maps. LOL
My response was more aimed at the worst case scenarios I read concerning Garmin’s subscription. Posts ranging from the suggestion that EU maps will only be once a year to Garmin not offering the guarantee once they discontinue the model. The chances of those things really happening is as likely as TT changing their offer next year to $120 instead of $70. I guess the point to be made that there are limits and asterisks attached to any of these offers and none are iron-clad, “no-way-out-of-it” deals that will never go up in price or change the terms.
You’re completely right. Tomtom’s offer seems to be more flexible and prices can (and probably will) go down when map data market value becomes cheaper.
It is really unfortunate that manufacturers of technical products have not come to realize that if they used a common platform more people would be inticed to purchase a product in that family of products.
But no, each time something comes out every manufacturer goes proprietory hence based forcing those that purchase to commit to them, which might be a good marketing approach.
But it also discourages many others ( like me) from buying into that product market in fear that they might purchase the wrong “version” “remember the Beta vs. VHS”
For my part, the reason I didn’t get any update for my garmin 350, it’s because it’s way overpriced IMO.
Single update: 70$ which is 60% of the price of the full product but with a data difference of less than 10%… Also, if the gps last a decent amount of time, I’ll have to buy two (or more) wich is more expensive than a lifetime update.
Lifetime update: 130$. In a few years, the equivalent of my unit will cost slightly more than that. So I might just stick with the actual mapping and change the unit in a few years. I might not get a better product nor I’ll save money but I’ll still have a warantee. Because mine is out of the short one year warantee. And what if I I lose it, it breaks or anything else? Risky bet. Also, the price is interesting compared to the single update but because it is way too expensive, the lifetime update is not a great deal after all. I can bypass an annual update and buy the full mapping for around the same price.
In the end, Garmin, Navigon and TomTom are all offering very good deals compared to what was previously available (nothing except annual updates). The TomTom offer is particularly atractive for those who anticipate keeping their PND for only a year or two. Navigon’s subscription has changed since the original offer, but is still very good at only around $20 year (2 years) when purchased at street sale prices. Garmin’s Lifetime should really appeal to those planning the use of their newly purchased device for at least two years or more, with street prices around $13/update if only used for two years, or less than $9/update if the subscription is used for 3 years. It’s very welcome news that map update prices are now a minor concern when considering a purchase from any of these three manufacturers. Any of these subscriptions deserve consideration for the respective owners.
I still consider Garmin updates too expensive (whatever are the others manufacturers offer). I could have said it another way. Why is a map update that is about 5% of change from one release to the next year release cost about 60% of the price of the full release? Anyway all my points are still valids.
When I was selling Garmin GPS, we were telling the clients to bypass one or two yearly update except if they are professionals on the road (small minority). The difference in the database is so small it’s not worth that amount of money. And in 2-3 years, the client might consider it’s not worth to invest that money in an “old” unit. I mean a 150$ unit in 3 years is a middle of the range unit this year. So the lifetime is really worth it if you have a high end unit. And like I said, what happen if it breaks when warranty is over, it’s lost or a theft take it?
For me NAVIGON remains to have the best and most crystal clear Map Program. The first to fully commite themselves to 4 times a year, full map releases, for the next 2 years for 99Euro. And for most devices even offer it for 19,95Euro if bought within 30 days. (In the US I believe it started at 3 Years and now went to 2 years?).
Anyway, how many people will ever use there PND longer than 3 years?
It was only because of this bold step of NAVIGON that TomTom and Garmin had to follow!
And the pricing of TomTom is completely unclear and forces you to first buy a new map.
And Garmin, tja, it has some strange timelimites and how the h%ll can you promise me a service for “Lifetime”!? Just for fun I should be a Garmin, put it in the closet for about ten years and then call Garmin in 2019.
Anyway, more important for me is how the PND itself is and I love my NAVIGON. My TT-One I de-activated.
I purchased a Navigon 2100max and just found out, from Navigon customer service, that Freshmaps are no longer available.
My Email:
I just purchased a 2100max with v6.5 and would like to update it; however, I am dismayed that everywhere I search retailers are out of stock on freshmap cards. I bought this unit after searching and finding freshmap cards for $15 to $39 dollars earlier this year. What is the status of this? If I cannot find one in the next few days I’ll be forced to return the GPS.
Their Response:
Dear NAVIGON Customer
Thank you for your inquiry.
Unfortunately not we are sorry about that, the freshmaps are not longer available, sorry.
Sincerely
pp Michelle Collier
Navigon has announced they are pulling out of the North America market for PND devices.
If I buy the TomTom one 130s here in Canada it come with Canada and US maps. Will it also hold maps of UK and how much would it cost for these additional maps.